The Culture That Allows Sensible Libertarianism
- 3 minutes read - 545 wordsSomething I learned through my love of the Netherlands, and the political alignment that grew out of it, is that what makes a harm-reduction attitude toward drugs possible there isn’t the law. It’s the social fabric.
It’s wound up in the terribly bourgeois culture of that lovely low land, a culture that (contrary to reputation) tamps down on people doing strange things. It’s in the reasonable guarantees of health care and of a decent retirement. It’s in unions and boerenkool, in trams and tea cozies.
It’s this social foundation that keeps people discerning “soft drugs” from “hard drugs” and using them in designated places, peaceably. The addicted are nurtured back to health, not incarcerated, and not left standing dumbfounded outside the one free toilet in eight blocks, the way they are in New York. The culture takes a bit of extreme behavior and says: that’s quite enough, thank you very much.
The confirmation that it is in the culture only required another data point: when tolerance came to the US, it was far less successful. I read The Atlantic’s “The Cities that said Yes to Drugs” with great interest. The upshot? Many kind-hearted governments wound up giving cover to pernicious evils: tainted drugs; open-air injection and drug markets; and downtowns that became ever more repellent to the moneyed classes whose dollars fund such programs.
I realize now that my free-cannabis attitudes as a younger man were tied to my default perception of how society would operate: something close to the home life I grew up in (no surprise there). Moderation, stability, and choice were all facts of my daily existence.
And I still think people should be able to do what they want in their own home.
And I still think that unevenly applied drug laws have largely been a tool to enforce racist agendas or to enable corruption. It was Theodore Roosevelt, as president of the NYC Board of Police Commissioners, who saw that uneven enforcement of the excise law was itself the corruption: it let police squeeze (German) saloon-keepers for payoffs.
But I can’t deny that I find it genuinely disgusting when someone is blazing a stinky, grating blunt on the corner of a block with an elementary school on it. And it is not a stellar feeling to watch parents pushing a stroller while passing a blunt back and forth over their newborn’s head.
I’d be delusional to think that wasn’t happening before New York legalized cannabis in 2021. But watching it happen, and watching it drag the Overton window along with it, is depressing.
Which echoes what certain authoritarian-leaning political figures have exploited in my own country: it was never really about the laws that constrained executive action. It was about standards of decency, implicit ones, upheld by people who aspired to them. The notion that “the virtuous man” and “the man who is president” would be cleft in twain was a leap in imagination that the founders fell short of.
Sensible libertarianism works the same way. The freedom to do what you want in your own home holds up only on top of a culture that, unbidden, says: that’s quite enough, thank you very much.
Cover photo: V&D department store, Leiden. Photo by Michiel1972, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0; resized.