The Culture That Allows Sensible Libertarianism
Something I learned through my love of the Netherlands, and the political alignment that grew out of it, is that what makes a harm-reduction attitude toward drugs possible there isn’t the law. It’s the social fabric.
It’s wound up in the terribly bourgeois culture of that lovely low land, a culture that (contrary to reputation) tamps down on people doing strange things. It’s in the reasonable guarantees of health care and of a decent retirement. It’s in unions and boerenkool, in trams and tea cozies.
It’s this social foundation that keeps people discerning “soft drugs” from “hard drugs” and using them in designated places, peaceably. The addicted are nurtured back to health, not incarcerated, and not left standing dumbfounded outside the one free toilet in eight blocks, the way they are in New York. The culture takes a bit of extreme behavior and says: that’s quite enough, thank you very much.
The confirmation that it is in the culture only required another data point: when tolerance came to the US, it was far less successful. I read The Atlantic’s “The Cities that said Yes to Drugs” with great interest. The upshot? Many kind-hearted governments wound up giving cover to pernicious evils: tainted drugs; open-air injection and drug markets; and downtowns that became ever more repellent to the moneyed classes whose dollars fund such programs.
Agentic Software and the Rubik's Cube Solver Fallacy
The tech sector is chasing the “software factory”: describe software in plain language, and agents build it. But what’s left for the humans? Are we editors? Acceptance criteria authors? Do we read the code? Or do we trade a certain amount of ignorance for delivery velocity, and let the tsunami of agent-written changes buffet our brains?
Currently the suggested answer is Test-Driven Development (TDD) at scale: humans focus on validation while the agents do commodity implementation. “Validated” code is then deemed shippable.
If this is our bar, I think we’re vulnerable in two ways:
- Validation as the goal loses the why. A solved Rubik’s cube tells you nothing about how to solve one, and it leaves you dependent on the platform that does know: someone else’s AI.
- Even when every unit validates, the magic is in between the notes. The worst failures are the ones where every component “works” and the system still degrades.
Manhattan Life: A Story in Three Scenes
One. I stand on the corner. A man walks past with a doodle hybrid on a leash in his right hand. In that same hand, a tray from the nearby Starbucks with three drinks on it. His left hand is empty.
Two. I walk the path he walked. He walks back toward me, the doodle on a leash in his right hand. In that same hand, a tray from the nearby Starbucks with two drinks on it. In his left hand, one empty cup.
Three. I pass the doggy daycare: no man; no doodle; no leash; no tray. On the pavement, a splash of coffee flung wide as a sea anemone, still steaming. In the window, a large dog paces.